Major Roles of Technology and Analytics together
towards Advancement in Clinical Trials
Goshiya A. Shaikh
JSPM’s Charak College of Pharmacy and Research, 1/2,
Nagar Rd, Kawade Wasti,
Wagholi, Pune 412207, Maharashtra, India.
*Corresponding Author E-mail: gass.pharmacy@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
For
hassle-free management and reduce this errors tour booking 75% as compared to
manual methods visual analytics is most sought-after technique in clinical
trials for data presentation it evaluates large number of data and makes it
easier to review dimensional database model and traditional relational database
model explode in self-service mode and can deliver results with Precision and
efficiency the graphs charts are few of the examples the promising future
looking at vigorously changing market and technologies health care system
adopting the good digital Moto for reducing cost and accelerate authorization
process. The terabytes of the machineries get involved and management is
looking after the easier on confidence systems to work on with Data Analytics
the safety and delivery system of Healthcare is improving gradually with
clinical professionals leveraging the information technology. The EHR is employed
to nullify management in patient care for hassle-free management and reduce
this errors to whooping 75% as compared to manual methods.
KEYWORDS: Analytics, clinical trials, data visualization,
electronic human records, clinical decision support.
INTRODUCTION:
Analytics,
the core element of medical research and information has a major role to play.
Nowadays as technology advances with the changing trends, even they need to be
more newer framed and productive strategies for improvement when it comes to
the healthcare system management, patient engagement, diagnosis and spending.
Information technology plays a very important role in the advancements of
significant business transformations as a main source of competitive advantage
[1]. Clinical trials have started adopting analytics far and wide, and are
adapting fast with changing tools of better management. Analytics are being
looked after as automated solutions and assistance to existing problems and
tasks.
A
term called as big data analytics has numerous benefits for the improvement of
services provided to the patients, to detect any kind of disease spreading as
soon as possible, to monitor the quality of the medical and healthcare
institutions as well as better treatment methods [5]. It is also very systematic
data analysis that helps to improve patient health and provides great
opportunities to healthcare professionals [6]. More clinical trials provides
strategies to reduce side effects and minimal cost. Educate people by health
education program especially risky groups about control, prevention any disease
transmission, and correct treatment. Base Camp should be followed frequently by
health teams to diagnose and alleviate health problems particularly infectious
diseases [7]. Planned way of method
development with the aim of drug analysis is critical to success for fast and
effective method development [8].
Analytics
gives the health information and data, decision support, patient support,
electronic communication and connectivity updated reporting and population
health. It helps to know at a very early stage if condition of any patient is
not as good as expected. Health analytics bids numerous methods for the
potential enhancement of patient care [14].
Analytics
has a common data model in which EHR has been involved which is processed by
means of different analytic techniques to stratify patients as high risk.
Unlabeled and free text databases such as mammography data can be transformed
into searchable and accessible collections that are usable for large-scale
health [15]. Analytics can supplementary real-time analysis of physiological
data streams in the neonatal Intensive Care Unit for early detection of
worsening medical conditions with considerable accountability and accuracy.
[16].
The
rule-based systems that are already in use can be enhanced by employing
analytics methods. Electronic Health Record (EHR) helps in decision making
in clinical workflow. Clinical decision support (CDS) systems that is clinical
decision support systems they help in reducing errors and give precise clinical
outcomes for example in pediatric Intensive Care units [16,17]. The Clinical
decision support (CDS) systems, which are designed to protect medication errors
are mostly based on commercial available software packages which rely on
relatively simple rules [18].
Analytics
has also been playing a major role in Healthcare applications outside of the
traditional inpatient and outpatient care settings where wearable monitors are
used when by the patients at home [19]. Such health monitoring systems also cut
down Health Care costs and their reduced by disease prevention and enhance the
quality of life with disease management and can be tailored to specific uses
such as intelligent health monitoring of the elderly in nursing homes and for
individuals with dementia or Parkinson's disease [20,21,22].
Finance
is another role played by analytics in clinical trials that is not only by
reducing cost but it also reduces time and human efforts, it shows that instead
of doing hard work one should do smart work also analytics is an effective tool
in Healthcare. Before finding errors in any buildings or rule based approaches
or any audits were done manually also identification of, simple errors were
also done manually and due to that, it was really time-consuming and
error-prone. Healthcare organizations can use analytics not only to improve
building practices browser to better manage resource allocation and demand
throughout the organization one example is to use analytics to determine these
factors impacting a patient length of stay [20,18]. Cost-reducing actions have
been directed and restrained using Analytics, and have profits making
interpositions such as using promoting analytics and Graphical information
systems to aim catchment areas [20,24]. A case in point to be given, one organization
use analytics and concluded that ineffectiveness at the radiology department
unfavorably extended a patient span of stay on preliminary estimates. The
authors then advocated the use of proactive analytics assessment of network of
activities to boost organizational proficiency [29].
Visual
analytics is the most trending and effective tool in scientific field. Large
amount of data is stored and when desired it can be viewed in very less time
using visual analytics software. Visual analytics is widely used because it
evaluates large and complex data sets and makes it easier for one to review.
There are two different database models one is dimensional database model and
the other is traditional relational database model. Dimensional database model
is used nowadays because it stores a large set of data and it makes the data
simple and easy to use by using Visual analytics tools. Visual analytics also
displays diagrams and graphs in order to identify when explore data. It can
also be used to visualize clinical trial data; it gives support and cuts down
work done manually to a considerable extent. It mainly has three benefits first
data can be explored in self-service mode, second the complete ideas can get a
clarity, Precision and efficiency in visual graph instead of tabular data,
third that one can view large volumes of filter data in lesser time compared to
traditional ways. [5].
Visual
analytics is the most essential part of clinical research and site selection in
which visualization performance analytics methods go hand in hand. Visual
analytics techniques can help understanding performance indicators in optimized
site works. Visual analytics can be a helping hand when findings need to be
clear and easy to analyze and evaluate. In addition, visuals can improve
communication and interoperability. With this in addition to it, Complex ideas
can also get Precision and transparency.
Data
exploration and hypothesis generation can also be enabled using visual
analytics tools within a specific group of data and it is a way that
facilitates better understanding. Visual analytics techniques are utilized in
three areas for analysis: 1) business purposes, 2) clinical operations and 3)
scientific research in various Healthcare related fields such as genomics
immunology and epidemiology [32,33,34,35].
A
research group used a visual analytics application in order to visualize EHR
data with an objective of improving patient’s care and they also described
the usage of the tool for chore that were difficult to retort with the
providers EHR software studying: hospital room allocation patterns, performing
follow-up studies and replicating studies among others [18]. To provide CDS at
the point of care the data visualization can also be used as a visual analytic
tool [36,37].
Focus
on other uses as well that vision and it helps that would be dashboards attach
Hospital include monitoring EHR alerts as well as dashboard for monitoring hand
hygiene, nursing metrics, supply chain performance, and other into clinical
guidelines. In Literature a lot of example the available division undertakes
has been helping health in Healthcare such as to track symptom evolution during
disease progression, to track performing pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamics
analysis, building detection models for disease surveillance and visualizing
outcome data [38,39,40,41].
One
way to enhance the process would be using social media as a platform. Social
media in today’s generation has more power than any other platform. For instance if volunteers
are wanted for any clinical trials we can make a page on every social media and
can broadcast it and people who fit in the eligibility criteria can opt in for
the same [42].
Additional
Method -
BIOMARKERS
APPLICATION IN CLINICAL TRIALS:
Latterly,
biomarkers has the premier role in clinical oncology. For the evaluation of a
drug therapy we employ "Imaging Biomarkers" which is well known on
the field of "pharmaco imaging". In the senior years it has become
endorsed. We are using this novel technology in Computed technology (CT),
magnetic resonance technology (MRI) and in position emission tomography (PET).
Biomarkers has been utilized for analysis of serum levels in medicine and drug
development process. But in the recent times, use of biomarkers from imaging to
genomics gripping attentiveness.
Some
characteristics/features of imaging biomarkers are as follows
1.
We
are utilizing non- invasion imaging technique for management and diagnosis of
disease on daily basis because of this now we clearly understood
pathophysiology.
2.
As
imaging biomarkers are directly related to the phenotype of disease so now it
become accessible to acknowledge co-relation between drug therapy and its
interaction / effects.
3.
Imaging
biomarkers illustrate structural and functional hallmarks which made it easier
to comprehend bioactivity of drug compounds.
4.
To
promote "translational research" it plays prominent role as it
provides assessment in human as well as in animals.
To
summarize, biomarkers focuses on results and integrity of imaging rather than
their theoretical applications. [43]
Most
hospitals uses the same analytical procedure for the care of various diseases
and disorders as those used almost ten to fifteen years ago, so we need to do
better for the patients in clinical trials. The main motto of digital health
care is to lower the costs and accelerate the drug authorization. In clinical
trials, patients have a right to access data and technology that could
influence their health. The floor of hospitals generated about tera bytes of
data, which is full of electronic health records. Physiological medical
monitors like medical monitor pulse oximetry, these are artifacts and they may
produce faulty conclusions so for that analytics can be employed with machine
learning, neural network in data auditing and it can use to detect error prior
to analysis [42]. Creation of EHR has bring about large amounts of data of
hospital and other health care organizations to cope and evaluate various
purposes. For professionals it is increasing in demand [43,44]. Via EHRs,
telemedicine and evidence based medicine using tools such as clinical decision
support systems and data analytics, the safety and delivery of healthcare is
improving and even clinical professionals leverage the information technology
[45, 46]
CONCLUSION:
The
future of health care analytics will involve of an ever-increasing ultimatum
for and application of erudite analytics methods and tools, for instance-visual
analytics to discover and scrutinize data with the aims of improving patient
care, growing proficiency, elevating resource utilization and distribution, and
augmenting decision-making at both the clinical and enterprise levels. Health
care professionals with experience and expertise in clinical informatics will
be required to put up a strategy and implement the forthcoming analytic
applications and advances of EHR and communication systems to meet those
necessities.
1. Dimpy Sachar, Harshmeet Kaur. Impact of Digitalization
in an Organization and its importance in Knowledge and Value Management System.
Asian J. Management; 2017; 8(1): 37-48. doi: 10.5958/2321-5763.2017.00007.5
2. Kalpana Kamnoore, M P Venkatesh, Balamuralidhara V, T M
Pramod Kumar. Regulatory requirements for conducting Clinical Trials in India.
Research J. Pharm. and Tech 2020; 13(3): 1517-1522. doi:
10.5958/0974-360X.2020.00276.0
3. Nilima Kanwar Hada, Mahendra Singh Ashawat. Ethical
Conduct of Paediatric Clinical Trials; Issues and Challenges. Res. J. Pharm.
Dosage Form. and Tech. 6(3):July- Sept. 2014; Page 156-160.
4. ThePancreasPatient, youtube channel,
topic-understanding clinical trials, http://www.AnimatedPancreasPatient.com
5. Clinical Trial Performance
Analytics: Data Is the Core of Research, https://conductscience.com/clinical-trial-performance-analytics-explained/.
6. Simpao, Allan F., et al. "A review of analytics
and clinical informatics in health care." Journal of medical systems 38.4
(2014): 45.
7. Manohar D. Kengar, Kiran K. Patole, Akshay K. Ade,
Sumesh M. Kumbhar, Chetan D. Patil, Ashutosh R. Ganjave. Introduction to
Pharmacovigilance and Monitoring. Asian J. Pharm. Res. 2019; 9(2): 116-122.
doi: 10.5958/2231-5691.2019.00019.4
8. Nisreen M. Ibraheem. Controlled Clinical Trials:
Comparison The efficacy of some Single Topical Scabies Treatment Modalities
versus Combined Topical Modalities. Research J. Pharm. and Tech. 2019; 12(3):
1361-1368. doi: 10.5958/0974-360X.2019.00229.4
9. Hamid Khan. Analytical Method Development in
Pharmaceutical Research: Steps involved in HPLC Method Development. Asian J.
Pharm. Res. 2017; 7(3): 203-207. doi: 10.5958/2231-5691.2017.00031.4
10. C.
Vijayabanu, R. Renganthan, S H Shahana Hameedha, J. Arokiya Monica4;. Clinical
Trials in Digital Era on Pharmaceutical Industry. Research J. Pharm. and Tech
2017; 10(11): 4047-4050. doi: 10.5958/0974-360X.2017.00734.X
11. Kudyba,
Stephan P. Healthcare informatics: improving efficiency and productivity. CRC
Press, 2010.
12. Erhardt,
Ramón AA, Reinhard Schneider, and Christian Blaschke. "Status of
text-mining techniques applied to biomedical text." Drug discovery today
11.7-8 (2006): 315-325.
13. Michelson,
James D., Jenna S. Pariseau, and William C. Paganelli. "Assessing surgical
site infection risk factors using electronic medical records and text
mining." American journal of infection control 42.3 (2014): 333-336.
14. Gotz,
David, et al. "ICDA: a platform for intelligent care delivery
analytics." AMIA annual symposium proceedings. Vol. 2012. American Medical
Informatics Association, 2012.
15. Rojas,
Carlos C., Robert M. Patton, and Barbara G. Beckerman. "Characterizing
mammography reports for health analytics." Journal of medical systems 35.5
(2011): 1197-1210.
16. Blount,
Marion, et al. "Real-time analysis for intensive care: development and
deployment of the artemis analytic system." IEEE Engineering in Medicine
and Biology Magazine 29.2 (2010): 110-118.
17. van
Rosse, Floor, et al. "The effect of computerized physician order entry on
medication prescription errors and clinical outcome in pediatric and intensive
care: a systematic review." Pediatrics 123.4 (2009): 1184-1190.
18. Korhan,
Esra Akin, et al. "Determination of Attitudes of Nurses in Medical Errors
and Related Factors." International Journal of Caring Sciences 10.2
(2017).
19. Resetar,
Ervina, et al. "Customizing a commercial rule base for detecting drug-drug
interactions." AMIA Annual Symposium Proceedings. Vol. 2005. American
Medical Informatics Association, 2005.
20. Simpao,
Allan F., et al. "A review of analytics and clinical informatics in health
care." Journal of medical systems 38.4 (2014): 45.
21. Tseng,
Kevin C., Chien-Lung Hsu, and Yu-Hao Chuang. "Designing an intelligent
health monitoring system and exploring user acceptance for the elderly."
Journal of Medical Systems 37.6 (2013): 9967.
22. Baig,
Mirza Mansoor, and Hamid Gholamhosseini. "Smart health monitoring systems:
an overview of design and modeling." Journal of medical systems 37.2
(2013): 9898.
23. Schouten,
Pieter. "Big data in health care: solving provider revenue leakage with
advanced analytics." Healthcare Financial Management 67.2 (2013): 40-43.
24. Bradley,
Paul, and Jell Kaplan. "Turning hospital data into dollars: healthcare
financial executives can use predictive analytics to enhance their ability to
capture charges and identify underpayments." Healthcare Financial
Management 64.2 (2010): 64-69.
25. Buell,
Dan. "Leveraging data and analytics to generate new revenue."
Healthcare Financial Management 67.4 (2013): 40-44.
26. Costantino,
Mary E., et al. "The influence of a postdischarge intervention on reducing
hospital readmissions in a Medicare population." Population health
management 16.5 (2013): 310-316.
27. Kudyba,
Stephan, and Thomas Gregorio. "Identifying factors that impact patient
length of stay metrics for healthcare providers with advanced analytics."
Health informatics journal 16.4 (2010): 235-245.
28. Whitham,
Diane, et al. "Development of a standardised set of metrics for monitoring
site performance in multicentre randomised trials: a Delphi study." Trials
19.1 (2018): 557.
29. Yang,
Eric, et al. "Quantifying and visualizing site performance in clinical
trials." Contemporary clinical trials communications 9 (2018): 108-114.
30. Tufte,
Edward R. The visual display of quantitative information. Vol. 2. Cheshire, CT:
Graphics press, 2001.
31. Thomas,
James J., and Kristin A. Cook. "A visual analytics agenda." IEEE
computer graphics and applications 26.1 (2006): 10-13.
32. Kumasaka,
Natsuhiko, Yusuke Nakamura, and Naoyuki Kamatani. "The textile plot: a new
linkage disequilibrium display of multiple-single nucleotide polymorphism
genotype data." PloS one 5.4 (2010): e10207.
33. Naumova,
Elena N. "Visual analytics for immunologists: data compression and fractal
distributions." Self/nonself 1.3 (2010): 241-249.
34. Chui,
Kenneth KH, et al. "Visual analytics for epidemiologists: understanding
the interactions between age, time, and disease with multi-panel graphs."
PloS one 6.2 (2011): e14683.
35. Mane,
Ketan K., et al. "Patient Electronic Health Data–Driven Approach to
Clinical Decision Support." Clinical and translational science 4.5 (2011):
369-371.
36. Mane,
K. K., Bizon, C., Schmitt, C., Owen, P., Burchett, B., Pietrobon, R., and
Gersing, K., VisualDecisionLinc: a visual analytics approach for comparative
effectiveness-based clinical decision support in psychiatry. J. Biomed. Inform.
45:101–106, 2012.
37. Goldsmith,
Michael-Rock, et al. "PAVA: physiological and anatomical visual analytics
for mapping of tissue-specific concentration and time-course data."
Journal of Pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics 37.3 (2010): 277-287.
38. Perer,
Adam, and Jimeng Sun. "Matrixflow: temporal network visual analytics to
track symptom evolution during disease progression." AMIA annual symposium
proceedings. Vol. 2012. American Medical Informatics Association, 2012.
39. Sornalakshmi.
K, Vadivu. G, Sujatha G, Hemavathi. D. A Survey on using Social Media
Data Analytics for Pharmacovigilance.
Research J. Pharm. and Tech 2017; 10(10): 3474-3478
40. Lo,
Yu-Sheng, Wen-Sen Lee, and Chien-Tsai Liu. "Utilization of electronic
medical records to build a detection model for surveillance of
healthcare-associated urinary tract infections." Journal of medical
systems 37.2 (2013): 9923.
41. Rajwan,
Yair G., et al. "Visualizing Central Line–Associated Blood Stream
Infection (CLABSI) Outcome Data for Decision Making by Health Care Consumers
and Practitioners—An Evaluation Study." Online journal of public health
informatics 5.2 (2013): 218.
42. Kochilas,
Lazaros K., et al. "A comparison of retesting rates using alternative
testing algorithms in the pilot implementation of critical congenital heart
disease screening in Minnesota." Pediatric cardiology 36.3 (2015):
550-554.
43. Pien,
Homer H., et al. "Using imaging biomarkers to accelerate drug development
and clinical trials." Drug discovery today 10.4 (2005): 259-266.
44. Lehmann,
C. U., Shorte, V., and Gundlapalli, A. V., Clinical informatics sub-specialty
board certification. Pediatr. Rev. 34:525–530, 2013.
45. Detmer,
Don E., Benson S. Munger, and Christoph U. Lehmann. "Clinical informatics
board certification: history, current status, and predicted impact on the
clinical informatics workforce." Applied clinical informatics 1.1 (2010):
11.
46. Google
search. URL: https://www.accenture.com/dk-en/insights/life-sciences/future-clinical-trials.
Received on 20.09.2020
Modified on 25.11.2020
Accepted on 14.01.2021
©Asian Pharma Press All Right Reserved
Asian J. Res. Pharm. Sci. 2021; 11(2):155-159.
DOI: 10.52711/2231-5659.2021-11-2-11